Get the App

Why our brains tell us we’re good multitaskers when we are definitely not

by Gemma Hartley

  • Share

When I started writing this article, I had three browser tabs open. Now I have seven because I needed to do a little more research before I dove in.

And then there were tangents in some of the links that led to things I might be interested in exploring some other time. There is a cup of tea over-brewing in the other room that I’ll eventually reheat, and I’d be lying if I said I wasn’t tempted to open up Facebook right this second. If I only had one tab open, I might be done by now.

Working on a single thing is hard for me, especially when it comes to completing a task that requires focus. As soon as the job at hand becomes difficult or uncomfortable I want to dash, or at the very least multitask so I feel like I’m being productive.

Giving my brain more things to juggle feels good, and it’s not because I have some unique personality quirk. Multitasking lights up an area of the brain that makes us feel like we are accomplishing more—even if evidence suggests otherwise. Which may be why we choose to multitask against our better judgment.

Plenty of research shows that our productivity significantly goes down when we multitask: we don’t perform as well, we make more mistakes, we take longer to complete our tasks, and though it gives us a jolt in the moment, it doesn’t actually make us better.

In fact, as little as a three-second distraction can produce significantly worse results. Researchers from Michigan State University found that while working on a tedious computer task, inserting a 2.8-second distraction doubled the errors made by study subjects. When they inserted a 4.4-second pop-up? The number of errors tripled.

While most people who multitask consider themselves to be very good at it, the truth is that they aren’t. There is a very small percentage of the population that researchers would consider “supertaskers”—people who can actually multitask—but the chance that you are one of them is very slim. As for the rest of us? Multitasking generally results in a 40 percent decrease in productivity. However, that may not be enough to dissuade you.

When we consider our multitasking efforts to be successful (even if they aren’t), we train our brains to release dopamine and increase our desire to continue this bad habit. But on the flip side, multitasking also increases stress levels and negatively impacts our short term memory. So how do we find a better brain boost than the short-lived high of multitasking?

The answer might be mindfulness. Cultivating a present-moment awareness can help us stay on task, even when we feel that urge to grab our iPhone while reading an article (like this one!) Training yourself to unitask—focusing on one thing at a time—actually increases productivity and performance. Taking less time to produce higher quality work can give you the same happiness you get with multitasking —but without the wasted time, energy, and letdown.

So next time you have work that needs to be done well, try coming to the task mindfully. Rid yourself of distractions and focus on the work at hand, and do so for at least 20 uninterrupted minutes. Just like with meditation, it may be uncomfortable at first, but it will gradually become easier and the results will speak for themselves.

The author of this post is an editorial contributor to Headspace. These are their views, experiences and results and theirs alone. This contributor was paid for their writing.

Gemma Hartley

Gemma Hartley is a freelance writer with a BA in writing from the University of Nevada, Reno. Her work has appeared on Yahoo Parenting, Ravishly, Role/Reboot, and more, in addition to being a writer for SheKnows, Romper, and YourTango. She lives in Reno with her husband, three young kids, an awesome dog and a terrible cat.

Meditation Made Simple

Meditation Made Simple

Start Meditating